If you priced a RAM upgrade this year and winced, a federal judge just gave you something to read. On 14 November 2026 she ruled that a lawsuit accusing the world’s three biggest memory makers of working together to choke supply can go ahead.
Key takeaways
- On 14 November 2026 Judge Noël Wise refused to dismiss a DRAM price-fixing class action against Samsung, SK hynix and Micron.
- The ruling is not a finding of guilt: the court only decided the buyers’ story is plausible enough to test with evidence.
- The buyers allege coordinated supply cuts, a pivot to AI memory, the DDR4 wind-down and no new capacity despite soaring prices.
- No class is certified and there is no settlement, so ignore ‘refund’ offers and simply keep your receipts.
The companies are Samsung, SK hynix and Micron. Below: what the judge decided and what she didn’t, why the case got further than the last one, and what it means if you’re buying memory or a PC now.
What the judge actually decided
The case is Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics, No. 5:26-cv-06345, in the US District Court for the Northern District of California. According to the court docket, it was filed on 25 June 2026 as an antitrust case and assigned to Judge Noël Wise.
The chipmakers asked her to throw it out. She refused. Business Upturn reports that her 14 November order gives the companies until 7 December to answer the complaint. It puts the first case-management conference on 12 January 2027.
Here is the part that headlines skip: this is not a finding that anyone fixed prices. At this stage a court has to treat the complaint’s factual claims as true. It only asks whether they tell a plausible story of an illegal agreement under the Sherman Act. Whether the story is true gets tested later, through evidence.
The buyers are 17 consumers and small businesses from five US states, bringing a proposed class action. “Proposed” matters too: no class has been certified yet.
What the buyers say happened
DRAM is the working memory inside every PC, phone and server. Three companies make most of it. The complaint, as Shattered reports, puts their combined share at more than 91% of global DRAM revenue in the third quarter of 2025.
The buyers don’t point to a single smoking-gun meeting. They describe a pattern of moves that, they argue, only make sense together. Tom’s Hardware lists them:
- Simultaneous production cuts from October 2022 to April 2023, during the last memory slump.
- A “coordinated pivot to HBM”, the high-bandwidth memory that goes into AI accelerators, pulling factories away from ordinary DRAM.
- Ending DDR4 production, with all three announcing the wind-down within about three months of each other.
- Not adding capacity despite soaring prices, which the complaint calls “the single most powerful supply signal the DRAM industry has ever produced.”
They add supporting details: strict new customer vetting, refusals to sign long-term contracts, and Micron’s decision to leave the consumer market. Micron announced on 3 December 2025 that it would stop selling Crucial-branded memory and storage through retailers, StorageReview reported. Shipments ran until the end of February 2026.
The headline number is that conventional DRAM prices rose 697% over 18 months. Treat that as an allegation. It is the buyers’ figure, not something the court has checked.

The chipmakers’ defense
Samsung, SK hynix and Micron say every one of those moves was a sensible decision each company made on its own. Demand for AI memory is enormous and HBM pays better, so of course everyone shifted. In a market with only three big players, they argue, rivals reacting to the same pressures will look alike without any agreement.
That is a real legal point. Antitrust law doesn’t punish companies for watching each other and making the same call. Economists call that “conscious parallelism,” and on its own it’s legal. To survive, a complaint has to show something more.
Did you know?
Antitrust law does not punish companies for watching rivals and making the same call. Economists call that conscious parallelism, and on its own it is legal.
“Hawks flying in formation”
The companies told the court they watch each other “like hawks” because competition is so fierce. Judge Wise turned the image around. Shattered quotes the order:
“But Plaintiffs’ allegations go beyond hawks watching each other; their contentions are more akin to hawks flying in formation, an activity that hawks ordinarily do not do.”
Read that closely. She is describing what the buyers allege, not what the companies did.
According to Business Upturn, she wasn’t impressed by everything. General remarks to investors about supply restraint didn’t count for much. Neither did executives meeting at industry events, or the fact that the market is concentrated. What tipped it was the combination: supply cuts, long-term bets on AI memory, factory decisions that would be hard to undo if a rival didn’t follow, and the customer checks.

Why this case got further than the last one
This is not the first time the big three have been sued over DRAM. In 2018 buyers sued over price rises in 2016 to 2018. That case was dismissed, and an appeals court upheld the dismissal in 2022. The chipmakers called the new suit a “rerun.” The judge disagreed, saying it covers a different period with new allegations.
There is older history too, and it isn’t just alleged. In 2005 the US Department of Justice announced that Samsung had agreed to plead guilty and pay a $300 million criminal fine for an international DRAM price-fixing conspiracy that ran from April 1999 to June 2002. It was then the second-largest criminal antitrust fine in US history. The complaint brings up that past, though a guilty plea from two decades ago proves nothing about today.
Memory is one link in a tightly controlled AI hardware chain. For the rules around the chips themselves, see our explainer on how AI chip export controls work. For the money flowing into the next generation of chipmakers, see TSMC’s $500 million fund.
Did you know?
In 2005 Samsung agreed to plead guilty and pay a $300 million criminal fine for an international DRAM price-fixing conspiracy that ran from 1999 to 2002.
What it means for you
The ruling won’t lower anyone’s prices this week. It doesn’t order the companies to make more memory, change prices or pay anyone. Here’s what you can actually do.
- Don’t sign up for anything yet. No class has been certified and there is no settlement. If you see a “claim your DRAM refund” site or email now, treat it as a scam.
- Keep your receipts. If the case ever ends in a settlement, claim forms usually ask for proof of what you bought. Save invoices for RAM, PCs and laptops. It costs nothing.
- Check what you really use before upgrading. On Windows, open Task Manager, go to Performance and then Memory, and watch “In use” during your heaviest work. On a Mac, open Activity Monitor and check the Memory Pressure graph. If it stays green, more RAM won’t help much.
- Match the standard and the slots. DDR4 and DDR5 aren’t interchangeable. Check your motherboard or laptop manual for the supported type, speed and maximum. Adding one module to an empty slot can cost less than replacing the whole kit.
- Own Crucial memory? The warranty still counts. Micron said warranty service and support for existing Crucial products would continue after the exit.
- Be wary of deals that look too good. Tight supply attracts counterfeit and relabeled modules. Buy from known sellers and check that the listed part number matches the maker’s own site.
What to watch next
The next date is 7 December, when the chipmakers have to file their answer. The case-management conference follows in January 2027. After that comes the slow part: discovery, where internal documents could show whether the moves were independent or coordinated. Then a fight over whether a class can be certified.
Memory demand is tied to the AI boom. Nvidia’s results this week are a good read on how much of that demand is still coming; we covered what to watch in Nvidia’s earnings. For more on the companies behind AI hardware, see our Tech Business section.
Frequently asked questions
Did the judge find that Samsung, SK hynix and Micron fixed RAM prices?
No. Denying a motion to dismiss means the complaint tells a plausible story of an illegal agreement. Whether it is true is decided later, after evidence is exchanged.
Can I join the DRAM class action or claim a refund?
Not yet. No class has been certified and there is no settlement. Treat any site or email offering a DRAM refund now as a likely scam, and keep receipts for RAM and PCs in case a settlement comes later.
Why are RAM prices so high?
The chipmakers say demand for AI memory pulled production toward high-bandwidth memory. The buyers in the lawsuit allege the three companies also coordinated supply cuts, which the companies deny.
What happens next in the DRAM lawsuit?
The chipmakers must answer the complaint by 7 December 2026, and a case-management conference follows in January 2027. Discovery and a fight over class certification come after that.
Quick quiz
What did the 14 November ruling decide?
- That the chipmakers fixed prices
- That the case can go ahead
- That buyers get refunds
The judge denied the motion to dismiss, so the case continues. She made no finding of wrongdoing.
Which memory type did the buyers say the chipmakers pivoted to?
- HBM for AI accelerators
- NAND flash
- DDR3
The complaint alleges a coordinated pivot to high-bandwidth memory used in AI hardware.
What should you do about the lawsuit right now?
- Pay to join the class
- Nothing, but keep your receipts
- Return your RAM
No class is certified and there is no settlement, so keeping proof of purchase is the only useful step.
Sources
- PacerMonitor: Garciaguirre et al v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. et al, docket 5:26-cv-06345 (N.D. Cal.)
- US Department of Justice: Samsung agrees to plead guilty and to pay $300 million criminal fine for role in price fixing conspiracy (2005)
- Tom’s Hardware: Judge denies motion to dismiss DRAM price-fixing lawsuit against Micron, Samsung, and SK hynix
- Business Upturn: Samsung, SK hynix and Micron fail to dismiss DRAM supply lawsuit
- Shattered: Judge keeps DRAM price-fixing suit alive
- StorageReview: Micron exits Crucial consumer business to focus on higher-growth segments





Write a response